New York’s best rated bars for a Tiki cocktail

A trip to New York? Amongst excellent renowned bars, speakeasy, classics and innovators the Big Apple is home to good bars for a Tiki cocktail.

We’ve created a list of the best rated New York bars according to public opinion. Do you want to prove them right? Here they go:


Super Power

Brooklyn’s bar welcomes you with a tropical neon and a “friendly welcome, relaxed atmosphere and friendly bartenders. And if you like oysters and cocktails, you’ll find your place here. The Super Power menu offers a specialty of super original oysters and Tiki cocktails such as Mezcal Mai Tai. This is a smoky variation of classic Mai Tai with spicy banana, mezcal, tequila, orange liqueur and mint. The fun is in the bar thanks to its pinball!

722 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY



Another Brooklyn bar in Carrol Gardens with a Latin soul but with a space in its heart for Tiki cocktails. From excellent reviews on the web and nominated for multiple awards, Leyenda prepares the last Wednesday of every month Tiki cocktails at its bar. Cocktails undoubtedly find their excellent reputation among critics. recommends Jungle Babbler: Caribbean rum, lemon, passion fruit, pineapple and grenadine.

221 Smith St. Brooklyn NY



A bar in Brooklyn… Don’t let the Neon Pink Flamingo fool you. Theme Tiki, Amazing Beer and Cocktails!” That’s how Flamingo himself describes it. This one-year-old bar at Gotham Market stands out for both its atmosphere and its service.

Gotham Market Hall, 590 Fulton Street, NY


Otto’s Shrunken Head

Otto is an unusual bar, in the sense that within its Polynesian atmosphere rock bands often perform here. They serve Tiki cocktails and seem to please tasters: Such fun-drinks with fruity flavors served in coconut shells and with umbrellas.

538 East 14th St. NY


The Polynesian

Recently they opened their terrace to enjoy outdoors in the middle of Manhattan, Polynesian Tiki cocktails created by their bartender Brian Miller. With good reviews, The Polynesian is a fine bar that proposes Mistaken Identity an original cocktail with cognac, gin, vanilla, 5 Chinese spices, yuzu, absinthe and fruit juices.

400 W 42 ST, NY, Pod Hotel 42


Don’t drink and drive. Enjoy responsibly.


Join the community on Reddit

Spirits Hunters is a community dedicated to spirits and the world of mixology. Feel free to talk about the world of mixology and bartending here!