New york statue of liberty with a cocktail

Spirits Hunters’ Top 10 Best Cocktail Bars in New York for Fall 2023

By Diana Pescador 15.09.2023

Fall in New York City brings a wave of innovative cocktail bars to the forefront, promising exceptional libations and unique experiences.

Whether you’re seeking a lively atmosphere or a tranquil escape, these establishments have you covered.

Located in the vibrant East Village, is the epitome of fun and creativity in mixology. Owned by seasoned expert Ignacio “Nacho” Jimenez, this Mexican-American cocktail bar offers a variety of unique and savory concoctions. The must-try mushroom-infused mezcal margarita and the memorable Mole Negroni are Instagram-worthy, but they’re not just for show – they’re downright delicious. The bar snacks, including pork belly tacos and birria grilled cheese, perfectly complement the drinks. For a group, the Tepache, a large format tequila, shochu, and yuzu blend, is a standout choice.

Address: 13 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003

2. Sip & Guzzle

This upcoming new bar is a tribute to the excellence of Japanese cocktail culture. Founded by industry veterans Shingo Gokan and Steve Schneider, this dual-concept izakaya boasts expertly crafted classics and elaborate arrangements across two floors. The main level, Guzzle, caters to lively crowds seeking expertly-executed classics. The lower level, Sip, offers a more intimate setting for those seeking a refined experience. Both levels feature Japanese cuisine curated by Michelin-starred chef Mike Bagale.

Address: 29 Cornelia St., New York, NY 10014

3. Darling

While Darling has been open for a little over a year, it has quickly become a standout in this part of town. Perched on the 47th floor of the Park Lane, it offers an unparalleled view of Central Park. The venue backs up the scenery with an impressive array of drinks and a lively atmosphere fueled by live DJ sets. Unique concoctions like “Here Comes Trouble” (tequila, wasabi, blood orange) and “The Parker” (single malt scotch, green peppercorn, melon puree) are not to be missed.

Address: 36 Central Park S, 47th Floor, New York, NY 10019

4. The Basquiat Bar

Located in the Great Jones Distillery, The Basquiat Bar pays homage to the iconic artist Jean-Michel Basquiat. The Art Deco-inspired space, spread across 28,000 square feet, hosts a pop-up experience reminiscent of Basquiat’s favorite watering hole, The Mud Club. It features signature cocktails, original prints, and a unique multi-sensory tour of the distillery’s Barrel Room. This experience is available through the end of September, open on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday evenings.

Address: 686 Broadway, New York, NY 10012

5. Titsou Bar

Tucked away in the Hotel Barrière Fouquet’s New York, Titsou Bar is a hidden gem that transports you to 1920s-era Paris. Accessible through an unmarked entrance in the hotel lobby, it exudes an intimate, dimly-lit ambiance. The barmen, sporting suspenders and handlebar mustaches, expertly craft cocktails, with selections veering towards the savory, featuring ingredients like rhubarb and carrot. The barrel-aged Negroni, with a mezcal twist, is a standout, as is their thoughtfully prepared gin and tonic.

Address: 28 Desbrosses Street, New York, NY 10013

6. Angel’s Share

A legendary fixture of East Village nightlife, Angel’s Share has recently reemerged as a speakeasy sensation in the West Village. The setting may have changed, but the scene remains the same: intimate, dimly-lit, and effortlessly cool. Whether you’re into Japanese whisky or elegantly balanced cocktails across all categories, Angel’s Share has something to offer every palate.

Address: 45 Grove St., New York, NY 10014

7. Time Out Market New York

Everything you love about New York City’s best bars can be found at Time Out Market: Terrific cocktails, skyline views, and happy hours to start your evening. Curated by some of the city’s finest beverage professionals, this market offers a diverse array of Instagrammable libations, including a focus on local brews.

Address: 55 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

8. The Long Island Bar

With a history stretching back five decades, The Long Island Bar in Cobble Hill retains its retro charm. The neon sign beckons guests from a distance, promising comforting environs and top-notch cocktails, along with a full menu. Despite the addition of outdoor seating, the crowds keep coming for the expertly crafted drinks.

Address: 110 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201

9. Attaboy

Originally located in the famed Milk and Honey space, Attaboy has been a classic LES cocktail leader since 2012. It ditches the speakeasy trappings, offering a casual yet expertly curated experience. The steel-brushed bar, once outdoors, now invites patrons to immerse themselves in the art of mixology.

Address: 134 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002

10. Bemelmans Bar

Located in the Carlyle Hotel, Bemelmans Bar exudes Old New York charm. Ludwig Bemelmans’ whimsical original murals adorn the bar, creating a unique and nostalgic atmosphere. While the drinks may come at a premium, the experience is unparalleled. The bar serves iconic cocktails, making it a must-visit for those seeking a taste of classic New York.

Address: 35 E 76th St, New York, NY 10075

These cocktail bars offer a diverse range of experiences, from hidden speakeasies to rooftop lounges, ensuring there’s something for every discerning palate. Enjoy your autumn exploration of New York City’s vibrant cocktail scene!

Welcome yourself to our Spirits Hunters Weekly Newsletter.

Don’t drink and drive. Enjoy responsibly.